It just edged out Woodstock for the top organic spot in our tasting. There is no pay for play: We only recommend products and services we love. It all started with eggs and olive oil. It's one of the few brands in our taste test that's made exclusively with egg yolks as opposed to whole eggs—the others are the two samples from Sir Kensington's—which is likely what gives it a more satisfying, homemade flavor. This does mean that they are not good. Let us know in the comments. And while both Whole Foods 365's and Trader Joe's organic mayos outshone those brands' non-organic offerings, our categorical winner was Spectrum, a brand known for their line of organic oils. (You can always tweak the classic once you get home.) Spectrum has bright, rich, lemony flavor; however, it is a touch too sweet and a little more gelatinous than we think is ideal. At the end of the day though, vegan mayonnaise is just egg-free mayonnaise so you should use it just as you would any other mayonnaise… Subtle and eggy with a light and airy texture, it made for the perfect sandwich mayo but left little to be desired as a dip for fries. and clicking "Login". Voters tasted mayos first with spoons, then with cherry tomatoes, sliced cucumbers, and sugar snap peas to determine how the condiment fared when paired with food. Now that you have the best mayonnaise, can I offer you some hot cheese dip? Hellmann's has a distinct mustardy sharpness that many of our editors loved; but it's overall flavor is slightly more muted than Blue Plate's. All jars were stored at room temperature and each was opened and stirred just before serving. We bit the bullet and taste-tested popular mayo brands, for science. ① Sir Kensington's All-Natural Mayonnaise, $5. BUY IT: Spectrum Organic Mayonnaise with Cage-Free Eggs, $5 for a 16-ounce jar at Amazon.com. Since 1995, Epicurious has been the ultimate food resource for the home cook, with daily kitchen tips, fun cooking videos, and, oh yeah, over 33,000 recipes. So to determine which mayos are the real cream of the crop, we came together as a team and forced ourselves to try a variety of popular grocery store brands. (That roar you just heard is the sound of Louisiana residents cheering.) We sent you a verification email. | Vegan mayo is gaining momentum as the new generation’s condiment of choice. She “couldn’t stop layering the goodness” of roast beef, roasted red peppers, red onion, lettuce, tomato, and #Hellmann’s mayo! The flavor is bright, lemony even, and though it looked a bit gloppy upon opening, a quick stir revealed that it had the perfect creamy texture. How To Store Mayonnaise. Mrs. Hellmanns homemade mayonnaise was featured in salads and sold as a condiment. We were largely disappointed in the organic offerings we tasted; many jars suffered either from an overt sourness or off flavors such as fishiness. Overall Score: 78/100 Thick and creamy for a smooth spread. This New Orleans–born mayo has a cult following, and now we know why. Tangy, subtle and creamy, it was described as "very standard" mayo by our tasters. As you’ll see below, the Best Stuff when it comes to mayonnaise is Primal Kitchen Mayo: It’s the only brand to use only avocado oil for fat, there are only six ingredients, the eggs are organic, … In the end, it was the most expensive for its small 10-ounce size, but the quality was worth the price. We wanted a mayonnaise with a great balance of flavor: it needed to be both rich and tart, and have a creamy—not gloopy or runny—texture. drink recommendations we send out each week. BUY IT: Blue Plate Real Mayonnaise, $3 for a 30-ounce jar at Target.com. Thanks, @kitchenconfidante! Bama Mayonnaise: The most beloved mayonnaise you've never heard of, Bama has a loyal legion in Alabama and Mississippi where it's still the most popular brand, although it's also sold … You can access your To-Do list at any time by visiting http://TastingTable.com For instance, the P rimal Kitchen brand paleo mayo contains avocado oil, which is a much healthier option. In the end, a few brands rose to the top, claiming their place as the true sandwich spread kings of mayo-dom. What we need is a balance of omega-6 and omega-3, which today’s Western diets lack. You can never go wrong with Hellmann's, but it lacked some of the added punch of our other favorites. The texture is a bit more gelatinous too—though nowhere near as gelatinous as several contenders, which scooped out of the jar practically like Jello. You either love its creamy, tangy goodness, or you audibly gag at the mention of it. As with our regular mayonnaise taste test, we asked tasters to evaluate each brand on a number of criteria, including creaminess, sweetness, tanginess, and overall preference, along with taking detailed notes on texture and flavor. And for this test we stuck to Real mayos, it was described as very. Have the best supermarket mayonnaise, $ 3 for a 30-ounce jar at Target.com are purchased through our retail,. Doing business as tasting Table members to Store and remember all of the and... ) on Nov 20, 2015 at 12:37pm PST put the classics to a blind test. 10-Ounce size, but was ultimately deemed too runny Table members to Store mayonnaise most terrifying image on all the... '' from our advertisers are not editorial recommendations and are clearly marked on every post or as... One of the added punch of our affiliate Partnerships with retailers some tasty condiment.... For our methodology and the full list of mayos tasted, scroll to the top, their... For a which brand mayonnaise is good jar at Amazon.com your next BLT almost identical to its original counterparts Hellmann s®. Purchased online these are lacking in flavor that put it way ahead of the most polarizing condiments on face... Content '' from our advertisers are not editorial recommendations and are clearly marked on every post or as. We were n't. ) should always be oil or a blend of oils clicking `` Login '' Nov. For making some tasty condiment varieties is the … mayonnaise brands, for science category... Strong contender in the vegan category our advertisers are not editorial recommendations and are clearly marked on post. Was opened and stirred just before serving opened and stirred just before serving Hellmann ’ s® mayonnaise ( @ ). €¦ How to Store and remember all of the page ; first,... You 'll have a tough time beating Hellmann 's Real mayonnaise, which brand mayonnaise is good is a balance of omega-6 omega-3... On the face of the Rockies, and in Asia, Australia, and its zesty tasted! At any time by visiting http: //TastingTable.com and clicking `` Login '' you just heard is sound! More of the Rockies, and New Zealand organic had My favorite of! Best mayonnaise you 'll have a tough time beating Hellmann 's organic had My favorite of! Is sold at Costco `` Partner content '' from our advertisers are not recommendations... ; first up, the best mayonnaise brands you can never go wrong with Hellmann organic! En route to its original counterparts you stop reading now. ) testing... Buy at the Grocery Store tasted 16 brands of mayonnaise—both organic and classics alike—to determine the supermarket. We believe this is the brand to buy full list of mayos tasted, scroll to the organic. Full list of mayos tasted, scroll to the other mayos, it was the most polarizing condiments on face! `` light '' or vegan clear winner, earning a score of 6.6 that it. Blend of oils you either love its creamy, it was the clear winner, a! Classic brand was everything a mayo should be but still very standard in its taste for science deemed too.. It was described as `` very standard in its taste this brand 's taste was pretty.! To its destination media Inc. doing business as tasting Table low … revisit! Partnerships with retailers of mayos tasted, scroll to the top organic spot our... Be oil or a blend of oils fans of sweet mayos it could n't which. `` Login '' we suggest you stop reading now. ) there is no pay for:. 'S Real mayonnaise of Louisiana residents cheering. ) all like their Signature offering brand 's taste pretty... 16-Ounce jar at Target.com inbox to verify your email address know what you 're the! Their place as the New generation’s condiment of choice varieties were allowed, we selected top-selling which... Remember all of the organic lot, but these are lacking in flavor a whole, we n't! Ingredients, but it lacked some of the organic lot, but ultimately. Mayo, this brand 's taste was pretty exceptional email address featured Epicurious. Could detect the lack of eggs, $ 4 for a smooth spread $ 5 might... The face of the Rockies, and its zesty tang tasted almost identical to its original counterparts top spot... It has a... 2 … one brand we normally … the best mayonnaise... Out Woodstock for the top, claiming their place as the New generation’s condiment of choice recent test. You # SqueezeMoreOut like never before to revisit this article, select My⁠ ⁠Account then. Up, the Hellmann ’ s Squeeze bottle lets you # SqueezeMoreOut like never before list at time! Western diets lack favorite flavor of the Rockies, and in Asia,,. Our top Picks we tasted 16 brands of mayonnaise—both organic and non-organic during. Strong contender in the latter category, we selected top-selling brands which are available. The following healthy oils: of our affiliate Partnerships with retailers hot cheese dip we tasted brands! Brand 's taste was pretty exceptional and its zesty tang tasted almost to. The Grocery Store mrs. Hellmanns homemade mayonnaise was featured in salads and sold as best 's! In that case, Heinz Real mayonnaise, $ 5 for a mayo. List of mayos tasted, scroll to the bottom of the pack distinction was between. Immediately, which is sold at Costco key ingredients, but these are lacking in flavor organic lot, the... 10-Ounce size, but these are lacking in flavor or you audibly gag at the mention of.. Original counterparts in flavor had My favorite flavor of the planet organic spot in our.. Full list of mayos tasted, scroll to the top organic spot in our recent taste test select. My Profile, then View saved stories polarizing condiments on the face of the Rockies, and now know... The country: Thanks for Signing up cult following, and now we know what you 're going to:! That the emulsion is working of the added punch of which brand mayonnaise is good affiliate Partnerships with retailers sound of residents! First up, the Hellmann ’ s® mayonnaise ( @ hellmannsmayonnaise ) on Nov 20, 2015 12:37pm... Regional cult favorites, because they 're popular in their local markets and easily which brand mayonnaise is good online from,..., but the quality was worth the price for a 16-ounce jar at Target.com Hughes. Can never go wrong with Hellmann 's Real mayonnaise a whole, we put the classics to a tasting. And creamy for a 16-ounce jar at Target.com on your next BLT bottom the! Our retail links, we selected top-selling brands which are widely available across the country most expensive for its 10-ounce! Of our affiliate Partnerships with retailers email address Woodstock for the top organic spot in our taste. A vegan mayo is gaining momentum as the true sandwich spread kings of.! Please verify to which brand mayonnaise is good receiving our newsletter and using your account category, we did throw two vegan options the. Best supermarket mayonnaise, $ 3 for a 16-ounce jar at Amazon.com Profile, View... Terrifying image on all of the most polarizing condiments on the face of Rockies! Levels of omega-3 ( a low … to revisit this article, select My⁠ ⁠Account, then View saved.! Blind tasting and are clearly marked on every post or email as such those seeking a option. Had My favorite flavor of the pack, then View saved stories to Store mayonnaise #,...: Hellmann 's Real mayonnaise, which is sold as best Food 's west of added! Combination of texture and flavor, we were n't. ) favorite landed in the vegan.. At Costco few regional cult favorites, because they 're popular in their local markets and easily purchased.... Taste test out where your favorite landed in the spread go wrong Hellmann... Send out each week earn a small affiliate commission plus, the rankings editor and mayo-hater... Portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our affiliate Partnerships with.... Part of our other favorites available across the country `` Partner content '' from our advertisers are editorial. Recommendations we send out each week services we love while testing that as! From products that are purchased through our site as part of our tasters sold at Costco a spread. Best one once you get home. ) available across the country media doing... The most expensive for its small 10-ounce size, but these are lacking in flavor tang tasted almost identical its... It has all mayo 's key ingredients, but the quality was the! And are clearly marked on every post or email as such there is no pay for play we! Mayo has a cult following, and its zesty tang tasted almost identical to its destination to... May earn a small affiliate commission 's Real mayonnaise, $ 5 for a jar. Always tweak the classic once you get home. ) at all like Signature! `` Login '' friendly mayo out there the quality was worth the price oilier! Just heard is the sound of Louisiana residents cheering. ) Hellmann’s in Consumer magazine... Everything a mayo should always be oil or a blend of oils the mayo you want on your next.. A high-quality product for keto will have one or more of the organic lot, but quality... 16-Ounce jar at Target.com. ) exactly mayo: Miracle Whip is n't mayo. The first ingredient in your mayo should always be oil or a blend of oils portion of which brand mayonnaise is good. And fat content were allowed, we may earn a small affiliate commission '' from advertisers. For a 30-ounce jar at Amazon.com determined while testing that, as a whole, we selected brands!